Back to Blog
SEO & Digital Marketing

The SEO Metrics That Tell You Nothing (And the Four That Do)

A
Arun Godwin Patel
November 13, 20266 min read

Rankings, impressions and domain authority make a good slide and a poor decision. The four measures that connect search to revenue, and how to read them.

Most SEO reports are built from the metrics that are easiest to put in a chart, which are not the metrics that connect search to revenue. The result is a monthly document that goes up and to the right while the phone does not ring.

This article separates the two.

This article is part of our guide to SEO, GEO and AI search, and goes further than measuring your website's SEO performance.

The four that tell you nothing on their own

Average position. An average across every query you appear for, including hundreds you do not care about. A site can improve its average position by losing visibility for broad terms it was never going to win, which looks like progress and is not.

Impressions. How often you appeared. Appearing is not being read. A page can carry 17,000 impressions and produce two clicks, which tells you the page is being shown to people it does not suit, and that is a finding rather than an achievement.

Domain authority. A third-party score invented by a tool vendor. See SEO. Not used by any search engine. Useful as a rough comparison between competitors, meaningless as a target.

Total keywords ranking. Vanity. Ranking at position 47 for nine hundred terms is not an asset.

None of these are useless. They are diagnostic inputs. They become misleading the moment they are reported as outcomes.

The four that do

1. Clicks on queries that indicate intent

Not total clicks. Clicks on queries where the person is trying to do something you get paid for.

Split your queries into three groups, as getting found online in 2026 describes: people trying to understand something, people comparing options, and people trying to buy. Track clicks on the third group separately. It will be a small number and it is the one that predicts enquiries.

A site with 400 clicks a month, 30 of them on buying-intent queries, is healthier than one with 1,200 clicks all on definitional searches.

2. Click-through rate at a known position

Not CTR overall, which is an average across positions and therefore meaningless.

Look at pages ranking between positions 5 and 12 and check their CTR individually. A page at position 8 should attract somewhere in the region of 3 to 6 per cent. A page at position 8 attracting 0.2 per cent has a title and description problem, not a ranking problem, and fixing it is an afternoon's work rather than a campaign, often alongside structured data.

This is the highest-return diagnostic in search, and it is the one most consistently ignored, because the report shows the position as good.

3. Enquiries attributed to organic search

The measure that matters, and the hardest to capture honestly. It requires that your forms record source, that phone enquiries get asked, and that somebody joins the two.

Even imperfect attribution beats none. If you know that roughly a quarter of enquiries mention finding you through search, you can size the channel. Without it you are optimising something you cannot value.

4. Whether you are being cited rather than clicked

Newer, and increasingly significant. AI assistants answer using your content without sending anyone to your site, which shows up as long conversational queries in Search Console with good positions and almost no clicks.

Do not read that pattern as failure. Read it as evidence you are being used as a source, which has value that the click count does not capture. Track it separately and ask the assistants directly what they say about you. See how to get your business recommended by ChatGPT.

The report worth producing

One page, monthly.

  • Clicks on buying-intent queries, this month against last
  • Pages at position 5 to 12 with CTR below 2 per cent, which is the action list
  • Enquiries attributed to organic, however roughly
  • Anything new appearing in conversational queries
  • One sentence on what changed and what you are doing about it

Everything else is diagnostic and belongs in an appendix nobody has to read.

Key Takeaways

  • Average position, impressions, domain authority and keyword counts are diagnostic inputs. Reported as outcomes, they mislead.
  • Track clicks on buying-intent queries separately. 30 of those beats 1,200 definitional clicks.
  • Check CTR at a known position. A page at position 8 with 0.2 per cent CTR has a title problem, not a ranking problem, and it is an afternoon's fix.
  • Attribute enquiries to organic however roughly. Imperfect attribution beats none, and without it you cannot value the channel.
  • Long conversational queries with good positions and no clicks mean you are being cited by AI assistants. That is not failure.

Frequently Asked Questions

Our agency reports improving average position. Is that meaningless?

Not meaningless, and insufficient on its own. Ask which queries improved and whether any of them are ones a buyer would type. An improving average driven by informational terms is real work that may never produce an enquiry.

What CTR should we expect?

Broadly, high single digits to low twenties at position 1 to 3, mid single figures around positions 5 to 8, and low single figures beyond that. It varies by query type and by how much the results page shows above the links. The useful comparison is your page against that rough expectation, not against your other pages.

How do we attribute phone enquiries?

Ask, and record the answer in the same place as the form submissions. It is unglamorous and it works better than any technical solution at SME scale. A single field on your enquiry record, filled in consistently, is worth more than a tracking implementation nobody maintains.

Is SEO still worth it if AI answers the question?

For considered purchases, yes, and the emphasis shifts. Being the source an assistant quotes has value even without the click, and the people who do click after an AI answer tend to be further along and better qualified. For high-volume low-value transactions the picture is less favourable.


Getting a monthly SEO report you cannot act on? Talk to Halo Technology Lab. We will look at your Search Console data and tell you which pages are one title change away from working.

Share this article

Enjoyed this? Get the next one by email

Practical AI playbooks, build logs and tool teardowns. One email a week, free, unsubscribe in one click.

See what’s in it first

Have a project in mind?

Let's discuss how we can help bring your ideas to life.

Get in Touch